I’m trying to put together a holiday movie marathon with timeless, classic Christmas films that still hold up today. There are so many lists online that I’m getting overwhelmed and I don’t want to waste time on ones that aren’t really beloved or rewatchable. Can you share your favorite must‑see classic Christmas movies, and maybe why they stand out for you?
If you’re trying to build a proper “classic Christmas movies” lineup and not just scroll mindlessly through whatever a random algorithm spits at you, here’s the short version of what I actually rewatch every December and why.
My Forever-Queue Christmas Classics
1. It’s a Wonderful Life (1946)
The one that looks slow if you just see screenshots but hits like a truck when you watch it. It starts dark, gets heavier, and then somehow turns into one of the most hopeful endings ever put on screen. If you only watch one “old” Christmas movie, make it this.
2. White Christmas (1954)
Bing Crosby, songs, dancing, technicolor, slightly chaotic plot. It’s like comfort food for your eyeballs. Very “I’ve seen this every year since I was a kid” energy.
3. Miracle on 34th Street (1947)
The original. Black and white. Courtroom drama meets Santa Claus. It’s surprisingly sharp, not just cheesy. Also weirdly good if you’re in a “I don’t believe in anything” mood.
4. A Christmas Carol (1951, a.k.a. Scrooge)
There are a million versions, but if you want that full Victorian “ghosts of regret show up to bully you into being a decent human being” experience, this one still wins. Super atmospheric.
5. Home Alone (1990)
Barely “classic” by age, but culturally it’s locked in. Between the slapstick and the surprisingly emotional scenes with the old man neighbor, it holds up better than it has any right to.
6. National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation (1989)
This is the “we’re all dysfunctional but trying” Christmas energy. Lights on the house, relatives invading, everything breaking. If your holidays feel chaotic, this is cathartic.
7. How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (1966 animated)
Twenty-something minutes, zero filler, perfect background while you’re wrapping gifts. The newer stuff is fine, but this one is the pure version.
A lot of the older stuff I’ve collected over the years is in random file types that modern apps love to choke on. Some are ripped from DVDs, some from old hard drives, some from who-knows-where. Instead of playing the “which app can open this” game, I just toss everything into Elmedia Player on my Mac. I can start the movie on my Mac and stream it straight to the TV using AirPlay, so I don’t need to plug in extra cables or move the laptop around.
If you’re building a Christmas list, start with those seven, see what sticks, then add your own weird family traditions on top.
4 Likes
If you’re trying to get an actually timeless lineup and not just “whatever was on cable in 1997,” here’s a solid, classic-heavy marathon that still holds up, even if you’re not super into old-timey stuff. I’m gonna avoid repeating @mikeappsreviewer’s list beat-for-beat, since they already nailed most of the obvious ones.
1. The Shop Around the Corner (1940)
Criminally under-watched Christmas classic. Jimmy Stewart again, but quieter and more grounded than It’s a Wonderful Life. It’s set around Christmas, very human, funny, and surprisingly modern in terms of awkward romance and workplace drama.
2. Meet Me in St. Louis (1944)
Not 100% “Christmas movie” front to back, but the Christmas section is legendary. “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” basically comes from here. If you want that bittersweet, nostalgic holiday vibe, this hits it.
3. Holiday Inn (1942)
Yes, there are dated elements, and you can absolutely side-eye some of it, but as a piece of Christmas movie history with Bing Crosby and the original “White Christmas” song, it’s still worth including if you care about the “classic” part of “classic Christmas.” I’d honestly pick this over White Christmas if you don’t want two very similar Bing musicals in the same marathon.
4. The Bishop’s Wife (1947)
If you like the cozy, magical side of Christmas instead of total sentiment overload, this one’s perfect. Cary Grant as an angel, a low-key love triangle, wintry setting, and a vibe that feels like sitting in an old church with candles lit.
5. A Christmas Story (1983)
I’ll disagree slightly with people who pretend Home Alone is the only “modern classic.” A Christmas Story might be the definitive “this is how childhood holidays actually felt” movie. It’s a little slower than people remember, but it’s hilarious in that “my family is weird but so is everyone’s” way.
6. Scrooged (1988)
If the super-faithful A Christmas Carol adaptations don’t quite do it for you, this modernized version with Bill Murray is dark, weird, and still oddly heartfelt. Great late-night slot in a marathon when everyone’s a bit tired and punchy.
7. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)
Honestly one of the best Christmas Carol versions, period. If the 1951 version is a little too gloomy for your crowd, this keeps the heart and story while being way more accessible. Plus the songs are actually good, not “let’s suffer through this because it’s for kids” good.
8. Tokyo Godfathers (2003)
If you’re open to animation and subtitles, this is a phenomenal, non-cheesy Christmas movie. Three homeless misfits find an abandoned baby on Christmas Eve and try to find the parents. It’s rough around the edges, funny, emotional, and absolutely sticks the landing.
How to structure the marathon so you don’t burn out:
-
Start light & classic:
- The Shop Around the Corner
- The Bishop’s Wife
-
Go into “big feelings” middle:
- Meet Me in St. Louis
- A Christmas Story
-
Then the slightly weirder / later-night picks:
- Scrooged
- Tokyo Godfathers
-
Optional musical bonus if you’ve got stamina:
- Holiday Inn or The Muppet Christmas Carol depending on your crowd
Between this lineup and what @mikeappsreviewer already mentioned, you can basically mix and match and end up with a full weekend of legit classics without wasting time on the “Hallmark-but-worse” tier.
If you’re trying not to drown in “Top 100 Christmas Movies Ranked By Someone Who Hasn’t Seen Half Of Them” lists, here’s a slightly different angle that plays nice with what @mikeappsreviewer and @reveurdenuit already posted, but doesn’t just echo them.
They covered a lot of the English-language canon, so I’ll lean into stuff that still feels classic and rewatchable, but isn’t always in the first wave of recs. Think “still timeless, but you’re not just programming cable reruns from 1995.”
Core marathon picks that actually hold up
1. The Apartment (1960)
Not marketed as a “Christmas movie,” but it takes place over Christmas and New Year’s and is low-key one of the best holiday watches ever. Darker than most (affairs, loneliness, office politics) but ends up genuinely sweet. If your crowd can handle something a bit more adult and bittersweet, this’s a top-tier choice.
2. Remember the Night (1940)
Barbara Stanwyck + Fred MacMurray before Double Indemnity. Starts as a shoplifting case, turns into a strangely tender road-trip-home-for-Christmas story. Feels old-school in a good way without being syrupy. Great if you want something “classic Hollywood” that nobody in the room has seen.
3. The Man Who Came to Dinner (1942)
Christmas-adjacent chaos. An obnoxious critic slips on the ice, gets stuck at a family’s home over the holidays, and torments everyone. Snappy, talky, very 40s humor. If your group likes fast dialogue more than big sentimental speeches, this is a fun curveball.
4. The Lion in Winter (1968)
OK, this is my one “trust me” pick. Medieval royal family Christmas reunion. They yell, scheme, undermine each other and weaponize affection. It’s basically the dark, prestige-TV version of Christmas Vacation. If you like your holiday viewing with claws, this is insanely satisfying.
5. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)
I’m with @reveurdenuit on this one, and I actually think it beats the 1951 Scrooge for most modern audiences. Tight runtime, legit emotional payoff, and Michael Caine acting his soul out while surrounded by felt. Works for kids, secretly amazing for adults.
6. Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992)
Here’s where I mildly disagree with @mikeappsreviewer: the first Home Alone is technically better, yeah, but the second one is peak Christmas vibe. New York at Christmas, Plaza Hotel, toy store, choir in the big church, all of it. If you only pick one for holiday mood, I’d go with 2 over 1.
7. The Holiday (2006)
Not “classic” by age, but it’s sliding into that comfort-watch territory. Cozy, romantic, snow, cottage, movie-score nerdiness. This is your modern palate cleanser between the black-and-white stuff so people don’t revolt.
8. The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)
I know some people file it under Halloween, but it works perfectly as a late-night Christmas slot. It’s short, visually rich, and anybody who’s a little allergic to standard holiday schmaltz usually vibes with this one.
How to structure an actually watchable marathon
Since @mikeappsreviewer and @reveurdenuit already gave great lineups, here’s an alternate order you can weave in with their picks so you don’t end up with 4 tearjerkers in a row:
-
Kickoff with cozy “soft” classic
- Miracle on 34th Street (from @mikeappsreviewer’s list)
- or The Bishop’s Wife if you grab that from @reveurdenuit
-
Slide into the “we’re adults with feelings” block
- The Apartment
- Remember the Night
-
Mid-marathon reset with fun/chaos
- Home Alone 2
- National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation or Scrooged for the slightly unhinged vibe
-
Late evening emotional anchor
- It’s a Wonderful Life (non-negotiable, they both already said it, they’re right)
-
Wind-down mix
- The Muppet Christmas Carol
- The Holiday
- The Nightmare Before Christmas if people are still awake and surviving on sugar
TL;DR:
Use the big tentpoles from @mikeappsreviewer and @reveurdenuit (It’s a Wonderful Life, one solid Christmas Carol, one “chaos family” comedy), then sprinkle in:
- The Apartment
- Remember the Night
- The Man Who Came to Dinner
- The Lion in Winter
- Home Alone 2
- The Muppet Christmas Carol
- The Holiday
That’ll give you a marathon that feels classic, actually watchable, and not just a copy-paste of the same five titles everyone already knows.
If you mash together what @reveurdenuit, @chasseurdetoiles and @mikeappsreviewer already threw in, you basically have “the essentials.” I’d tweak the lineup slightly so it feels less like homework and more like a hangout.
Anchor must-watches that still feel alive:
- It’s a Wonderful Life
I agree with everyone: schedule it once people are warmed up, not first. Opening with attempted-suicide vibes is a rough choice for 2 p.m. - Miracle on 34th Street (1947)
This is your gateway black‑and‑white. Put it early in the day. Even skeptics usually get hooked. - National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation
I’d prioritize this over Home Alone if your group skews adult. It captures “holiday meltdown” better than anything.
Where I’d disagree slightly:
- I’d cap Home Alone at the first one. For a marathon, doing both 1 and 2 back to back is overkill. Pick whichever setting your crew prefers: suburb chaos or New York at Christmas.
- I wouldn’t stack too many A Christmas Carol versions. One good pick is enough. If you want emotional clarity and jokes, go with The Muppet Christmas Carol over the 1951 version for mixed-age groups.
Underrated “feel classic but not dusty” picks:
- The Shop Around the Corner (1940)
Precursor to You’ve Got Mail, set around Christmas. Light, witty, great bridge from modern romcom tastes to older stuff. - The Bishop’s Wife (1947)
If you want “old Hollywood glow” and something softer between heavier films, this works better than yet another Santa story. - Meet Me in St. Louis (1944)
Not 100 percent Christmas but the holiday segment plus “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” is peak nostalgia.
Order that keeps people from tapping out:
- Afternoon warmup: Miracle on 34th Street
- Classic romance slot: The Shop Around the Corner
- Food break chaos: National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation
- Prime-time heavy hitter: It’s a Wonderful Life
- Wind-down: The Muppet Christmas Carol
- Late-night optional: Nightmare Before Christmas or Meet Me in St. Louis depending on crowd mood
On the tech side, since a few of these only exist in weird rips or old formats for a lot of people, using something like Elmedia Player on a Mac is actually practical. It tends to swallow odd file types without complaining and streams nicely to a TV, so you are not fighting codecs in the middle of the marathon.
Pros of Elmedia Player:
- Plays a wide range of formats, including some that default apps choke on
- Handy for organizing a “Christmas” playlist and just letting it run
- AirPlay/streaming support so you can keep the laptop near the snacks instead of the TV
- More control over subtitles and audio than the stock player
Cons of Elmedia Player:
- Mac only, so useless if your setup is Windows or strictly smart‑TV apps
- Free version is fine, but some nicer features sit behind a paid tier
- Interface has more options than casual users may want, small learning curve
- Overkill if you mostly stream from big platforms and rarely touch local files
Where @reveurdenuit leans nicely sentimental and @chasseurdetoiles goes a bit more offbeat and @mikeappsreviewer sticks close to the mainstream canon, you can steal their overlapping core (It’s a Wonderful Life, one Christmas Carol, one chaos comedy) and then swap in one or two of the less-talked-about titles above. That way your marathon feels “classic” without being exactly the same list everyone has seen reposted for ten years.